β˜… Now fortified with reviews β˜… We interrupt your Saturday morning cartoons to bring you these important messages β˜… More fiber, less frosted β˜… β˜… Now fortified with reviews β˜… We interrupt your Saturday morning cartoons to bring you these important messages β˜… More fiber, less frosted β˜…
Saturday Boring Cereal
Terms and conditions apply

Store Policy

The methodology, posted by the register where nobody reads it. Every rule below is actually followed, which is the least advertising-like thing on this website.

Β§1 β€” The Taste Scale

Every cereal is scored 0–10, decimals allowed. The scale is inherited from years of careful record-keeping and will not be changed, recalibrated, or explained. An 8.5 is a very good morning. Nothing has earned a 10. Nothing may ever earn a 10.

Β§2 β€” The Numbers

Nutrition is transcribed from the physical box and cross-checked against USDA FoodData Central where possible. The label lists values per serving, and every box states a different serving, so this store scales them all to 100 grams before showing or grading them. The label's serving size is still noted on each box's page. When a label doesn't state a value β€” protein %DV, poly/mono fats β€” this store prints β€œnot listed” rather than inventing a number. The FDA only requires protein %DV when a protein claim is made; most boxes stay quiet, and so do we.

Β§3 β€” What Gets Shelved

Granolas and healthier cereals, weighted toward things a functioning adult eats on purpose: flakes, clusters, high-fiber, high-protein. Neon marshmallow products are outside the jurisdiction of this regulatory body.

Protein bars, cereal bars and protein snacks are stocked too, each in its own aisle. They are scored by the same rules as the cereals and ranked only against their own aisle. A protein bar packs more protein per 100 grams than any cereal, so letting it compete would hand it every cereal's place.

Milk is stocked too, so you can see what the milk in the bowl would score. The fat-free, 1% and 2% entries are not one brand. They are the typical US label: the median of about 190 real labels of each kind in USDA's Branded Foods database.

Β§4 β€” On Clusters

Flakes are only acceptable when accompanied by clusters. This is store policy. Complaints may be filed with the spoon.

Β§5 β€” Returns

All opinions are final. No refunds. Total regret: 0.00.

Β§6 β€” The Tier

The Taste score answers one question: is it good. The Tier answers a nosier one β€” is it good for you, too. It is half the spoon's verdict and half the box's own numbers, weighed per 100 grams so a box can't win by declaring a bigger bowl. The spoon's half is squared before it counts, so a 9 keeps 81 points, a 7 keeps 49, and a 3 keeps 9. A cereal that tastes bad stays bad no matter how many vitamins it brags about: even a perfect label can't lift a 3 into the top tiers. On the numbers side, protein counts most (40%), then low total sugar (30%), then fiber (20%), then low saturated fat (10%); only the figures printed on the label are admitted as evidence. Protein is judged by its % Daily Value, which the label adjusts for protein quality: 35% per 100 grams earns full marks. When a box prints only grams, we assume 1.25% DV per gram and say so. Full marks for fiber is 12 grams; 20 grams of sugar or 8 grams of saturated fat scores zero. Going past that line costs extra, and the cost grows fast: 10% over costs almost nothing, 50% over costs 15 points of the numbers half, and double the line costs 60. A box can't hide one alarming number behind three good ones. A cereal that tastes like a birthday but eats like dessert lands mid-pack, and a virtuous brick nobody enjoys does no better. Tiers run S, A, B, C, D, F, handed out like a strict lunchroom. S is a blue ribbon pinned on the best box on the cereal shelf β€” shared when boxes tie at the top, and taken away the moment something outscores it; an A is already a very good morning. Bars and snacks are held to the same lines, so a letter means the same thing in every aisle. Unrated boxes get no tier, because we will not invent a taste we never had. Milk gets only the numbers half, shown as its Health score out of ten, with no taste score and no letter. It is shown and graded per 250 mL, about what goes on a bowl of cereal, because 100 grams of milk is less than half a glass. Milk has no fiber and a cup carries about 12 grams of lactose, so it lands between 3.5 and 4 out of 10 at any fat level. Compare it with other milks, not with a dry cereal. The formula lives in the code, not on this poster; change a target and every box on the shelf is re-ranked at once.